Top Tire Shops in Barrie
N2Y Tire & Performance
Tire and performance shop specializing in lifts, wheels, and custom fitment.
Looking for the best Tire Shops in Barrie? This list ranks 10 local Tire Shops businesses, selected for local presence, service quality, and relevance to Barrie-area customers.
How We Selected This List
MBM ranks Barrie businesses in this category by local presence, service breadth, and relevance to Barrie-area customers. Listings are reviewed periodically for accuracy — see the "Updated" date below.
Why It Made the List: The highest review volume of any tire shop in Barrie, with reviewers consistently praising a genuinely clean, professional shop and staff who take the extra time to dial in fitment perfectly on lift and wheel installs.
Phone: (705) 739-4130
Address: 20 Lennox Dr, Barrie, ON L4N 9V8 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.8★ (542 reviews)
Tire Depot
Tire retailer and installer offering seasonal changeovers.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers describe honest advice that has occasionally saved them from replacing tires that still had life left, though one review describes a mix-up over which rim size was ordered — confirm rim size in writing before your appointment.
Phone: (705) 722-7266
Address: 110 Anne St S #15, Barrie, ON L4N 2E3 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.6★ (356 reviews)
Superior Tire & Auto - Barrie
Tire shop and auto repair centre also handling custom brake conversions.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise a shop willing to take on unusual jobs — including converting a classic Buick from drum to disc brakes — with genuinely friendly, unhurried customer service.
Phone: (705) 719-2909
Address: 384 Yonge St, Barrie, ON L4N 6J7 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.8★ (333 reviews)
Paul Tire Change
Tire shop offering fast flat repairs and seasonal changeovers.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise fast, friendly emergency tire service — including a highway blowout resolved without an appointment — at consistently lower prices than competitors.
Phone: (705) 717-8006
Address: 36 Ellen St, Barrie, ON L4N 3A3 (View on Map)
Rating: 5.0★ (238 reviews)
Consumers Tire Barrie
Tire retailer known for transparent, no-hidden-cost pricing.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise clearly quoted pricing with no surprises, along with manufacturer rebate programs staff proactively mention to save customers money.
Phone: (705) 252-8473
Address: 31 King St #4, Barrie, ON L4N 6B5 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.9★ (236 reviews)
Rolling Tires Barrie
Tire shop also offering AC recharge and general repair services.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise no-upsell honesty, including specific advice to skip premium parts when a standard part will do the job just as well.
Phone: (705) 796-6789
Address: 97 Bradford St, Barrie, ON L4N 3A7 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.8★ (193 reviews)
DT Tires service Discount tyres Barrie tires & rims
Discount tire shop handling both new tire sales and emergency roadside swaps.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers describe fast, fair-priced emergency tire swaps even on short notice, though the discount positioning means service can feel less polished than higher-end shops — the pricing and speed are the main draw here.
Phone: (705) 896-3901
Address: 4 Ferris Ln, Barrie, ON L4M 2X7 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.2★ (192 reviews)
Jb Tire Tec
Tire shop handling quick rim and tire swaps, including for electric vehicles.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers describe fast, professional service even for newer EV models, though one detailed review describes a tire installed incorrectly and going flat shortly after — ask the technician to double-check the seal before you drive off.
Phone: (647) 271-2015
Address: 419 Huronia Rd Unit 3, Barrie, ON L4N 9B3 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.8★ (184 reviews)
Mapleview Tire (TreadPro Tire Center)
Family-run tire shop known for fast turnaround from call to installation.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise a family-run team that gets customers rolling within an hour of an initial call, with proactive handling of unexpected issues like a cracked rim discovered mid-service.
Phone: (705) 999-4424
Address: 224 Bradford St, Barrie, ON L4N 3B6 (View on Map)
Rating: 5.0★ (155 reviews)
New 2 You Tire Sales & Service - Used Tire Location
Used and new tire shop offering budget-friendly options.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise a comfortable, no-pressure experience for female customers and patient staff who never make anyone feel silly for asking questions.
Phone: (705) 735-1314
Address: 461 Dunlop St W Unit 12, Barrie, ON L4N 9W3 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.9★ (138 reviews)
Are You a Local Business Owner?
Get featured on Momo Barrie Magazine and connect with thousands of local customers. It's affordable, effective, and supports our mission to help Barrie businesses thrive.
Get Featured for only $9.99/monthFrequently Asked Questions
Who are the top Tire Shops in Barrie?
The businesses listed above are among Barrie's most established Tire Shops providers, based on local presence and service reputation.
How do I choose the right Tire Shops provider in Barrie?
Compare services offered, request quotes from a few providers, and check recent local reviews before deciding.
How often is this list updated?
MBM reviews this list periodically for accuracy. See the "Updated" date below.
Updated: September 2026
