Top Insurance Brokers in Barrie
BrokerLink
Large insurance brokerage handling home, auto, and business policies.
Looking for the best Insurance Brokers in Barrie? This list ranks 10 local Insurance Brokers businesses, selected for local presence, service quality, and relevance to Barrie-area customers.
How We Selected This List
MBM ranks Barrie businesses in this category by local presence, service breadth, and relevance to Barrie-area customers. Listings are reviewed periodically for accuracy — see the "Updated" date below.
Why It Made the List: The highest review volume of any insurance brokerage in Barrie, with reviewers consistently praising individual brokers by name for patiently explaining recent auto insurance changes and finding competitive rates.
Phone: (705) 728-9921
Address: 128 Wellington St W Ste 103, Barrie, ON L4N 8J6 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.7★ (445 reviews)
Bevan Insurance
Insurance brokerage handling home, auto, and commercial policies for over 25 years.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise fast turnaround on urgent coverage requests and staff who take the time to fully review and explain policy options before recommending changes.
Phone: 1-800-667-9810
Address: 400 Bayfield St Ste 246, Barrie, ON L4M 5A1 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.8★ (332 reviews)
Westland Insurance
Insurance brokerage handling personal auto and home policies.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers describe helpful, responsive advisors, though a couple of detailed reviews describe inconsistent service quality between staff and frustration reaching the right person during a long-term policy dispute — ask to work with a specific advisor you trust going forward.
Phone: (705) 721-4755
Address: 431 Huronia Rd #12, Barrie, ON L4N 9B3 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.4★ (210 reviews)
All-Risks Insurance Brokers Limited
Insurance brokerage handling home, auto, and business coverage.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise brokers who stay on top of insurance company claims until clients are satisfied, with new small business owners specifically noting they felt genuinely cared for.
Phone: (705) 881-7774
Address: 48 Alliance Blvd #210, Barrie, ON L4M 5K3 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.7★ (172 reviews)
Navacord (formerly Insurance Store)
Insurance brokerage handling home and auto policy quotes.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise a specific broker for quick, thorough, and unrushed service, taking the time to introduce clients to insurance details they hadn't previously understood.
Phone: (705) 737-0136
Address: 299 Lakeshore Dr Ste 202, Barrie, ON L4N 7Y9 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.7★ (100 reviews)
BrokerUnion Insurance Brokerage
Insurance brokerage handling personal and business insurance needs.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise brokers who explain options clearly without pressure, with several describing meaningful savings after switching from their previous provider.
Phone: (705) 252-1900
Address: 494 Veterans Dr #3, Barrie, ON L4N 9J5 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.8★ (44 reviews)
Will Marshall Insurance Brokers Ltd
Insurance brokerage handling personal and commercial insurance.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers praise a specific broker's deep expertise and willingness to point out coverage gaps clients hadn't considered, though one review describes a billing mix-up after a policy cancellation that took a couple of weeks to resolve.
Phone: (705) 726-2551
Address: 264 Burton Ave, Barrie, ON L4N 5W4 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.4★ (40 reviews)
Innisfil Insurance
Insurance brokerage handling personal and business insurance for Barrie and Innisfil.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently describe extraordinary responsiveness, including a broker who called over a dozen times in one day to keep a client updated on a complex request.
Phone: (416) 815-2627
Address: 2109 Wilson St, Innisfil, ON L9S 0N8 (View on Map)
Rating: 5.0★ (39 reviews)
Billyard Insurance Group - Barrie
Insurance brokerage franchise handling home and auto insurance.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers praise specific brokers who go above and beyond to find the right fit, though one detailed review describes serious difficulty cancelling a policy with unanswered calls — confirm cancellation requests in writing and follow up if you don't hear back promptly.
Phone: (705) 908-0055
Address: 80 Bradford St Unit 150, Suite #300, Barrie, ON L4N 6S7 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.8★ (33 reviews)
R.K. Mooney Insurance Brokers
Independent insurance brokerage handling home, auto, and investment property coverage.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise personalized, responsive service from a smaller brokerage, including help closing an investment property purchase with an insurance binder delivered within 24 hours.
Phone: (705) 726-9941
Address: #7, 20 Bell Farm Rd #7, Barrie, ON L4M 6E4 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.7★ (17 reviews)
Are You a Local Business Owner?
Get featured on Momo Barrie Magazine and connect with thousands of local customers. It's affordable, effective, and supports our mission to help Barrie businesses thrive.
Get Featured for only $9.99/monthFrequently Asked Questions
Who are the top Insurance Brokers in Barrie?
The businesses listed above are among Barrie's most established Insurance Brokers providers, based on local presence and service reputation.
How do I choose the right Insurance Brokers provider in Barrie?
Compare services offered, request quotes from a few providers, and check recent local reviews before deciding.
How often is this list updated?
MBM reviews this list periodically for accuracy. See the "Updated" date below.
Updated: September 2026
