Top Ice Cream & Dessert Shops in Barrie
D Spot Desserts Barrie
Late-night dessert shop known for crepes, waffles, and kunafa chocolate.
Looking for the best Ice Cream Shops in Barrie? This list ranks 10 local Ice Cream Shops businesses, selected for local presence, service quality, and relevance to Barrie-area customers.
How We Selected This List
MBM ranks Barrie businesses in this category by local presence, service breadth, and relevance to Barrie-area customers. Listings are reviewed periodically for accuracy — see the "Updated" date below.
Why It Made the List: The highest review volume of any dessert shop in Barrie, with reviewers consistently praising generous portions and unique offerings like kunafa chocolate — though several reviews describe inconsistent front-counter service and a rigid no-substitution policy on sauces.
Phone: (705) 726-5222
Address: 279 Yonge St Unit 15, Barrie, ON L4N 7T9 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.6★ (2,003 reviews)
Holy Shakes Desserts, Cafe & Mash-Up Eatery
Playful, neon-lit dessert cafe combining milkshakes with a savoury halal menu.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise a fun, Instagram-worthy atmosphere paired with genuinely good food, with staff who take time to walk first-time visitors through the extensive menu.
Phone: (705) 721-0444
Address: 165 Wellington St W Unit 13, Barrie, ON L4N 1L7 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.8★ (779 reviews)
Marble Slab Creamery
Ice cream chain known for mix-in flavours blended fresh on a cold stone.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers praise a wide flavour variety and a couple of standout staff members who consistently deliver friendly service, though several reviews describe inconsistent order accuracy and a refused cake customization — service quality appears to vary noticeably by which staff member is working.
Phone: (705) 720-2663
Address: 636 Yonge St Unit D1-A, Barrie, ON L4N 4E6 (View on Map)
Rating: 3.8★ (341 reviews)
Swirleez Frozen Yogurt
Self-serve frozen yogurt shop with a wide selection of flavours and toppings.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers describe a solid self-serve selection, though several reviews describe pricing that feels steep for the portion, and one review describes an unhonoured gift certificate after an ownership change — worth confirming pricing and any promotions before filling your cup.
Phone: (705) 302-7893
Address: 89 Dunlop St E #101, Barrie, ON L4M 1A7 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.4★ (297 reviews)
La Diperie Bayfield
Dessert shop open until 2am, offering soft serve, donuts, crepes, and bubble tea.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers praise a huge dessert menu and friendly owner, though several reviews describe inconsistent soft-serve quality and machines shutting down before posted closing hours — calling ahead late at night is worth it if soft serve is the goal.
Phone: (705) 503-6824
Address: 360 Bayfield St, Barrie, ON L4M 3C4 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.0★ (150 reviews)
Bake & Shake
Dessert and milkshake shop with two Barrie locations, known for croffles and Dubai-style kunafa strawberries.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise standout specialty shakes and the kunafa strawberry dessert, with friendly owners frequently mentioned by name at both locations.
Phone: (249) 733-6050
Address: 221 Cundles Rd E, Barrie, ON L4M 6L5 (View on Map)
Rating: 5.0★ (49 reviews)
Scoops & Cones
Ice cream stand along the Barrie waterfront boardwalk.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers praise a wide flavour selection and friendly staff right on the boardwalk, though a couple of reviews describe inconsistent operating hours and rising prices — a great stop when it's open, but confirm hours before making a special trip.
Address: 45 Lakeshore Dr, Barrie, ON L4N 9R2 (View on Map)
Rating: 3.9★ (57 reviews)
Shake Therapy Barrie
Specialty milkshake shop with elaborate, loaded toppings.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers praise the creamy, flavourful shakes, though several reviews describe running out of key ingredients and inconsistent stock — worth checking availability before ordering something specific for pickup or delivery.
Phone: (705) 727-1116
Address: 145 Mapleview Dr W, Barrie, ON L4N 9H7 (View on Map)
Rating: 3.7★ (53 reviews)
Are You a Local Business Owner?
Get featured on Momo Barrie Magazine and connect with thousands of local customers. It's affordable, effective, and supports our mission to help Barrie businesses thrive.
Get Featured for only $9.99/monthFrequently Asked Questions
Who are the top Ice Cream Shops in Barrie?
The businesses listed above are among Barrie's most established Ice Cream Shops providers, based on local presence and service reputation.
How do I choose the right Ice Cream Shops provider in Barrie?
Compare services offered, request quotes from a few providers, and check recent local reviews before deciding.
How often is this list updated?
MBM reviews this list periodically for accuracy. See the "Updated" date below.
Updated: September 2026
