Top Pizza Restaurants in Barrie
Pie Wood Fired Pizza Joint
Wood-fired pizza restaurant on the waterfront with an extensive pizza and dip menu.
Looking for the best Pizza Restaurants in Barrie? This list ranks 10 local Pizza Restaurants businesses, selected for local presence, service quality, and relevance to Barrie-area customers.
How We Selected This List
MBM ranks Barrie businesses in this category by local presence, service breadth, and relevance to Barrie-area customers. Listings are reviewed periodically for accuracy — see the "Updated" date below.
Why It Made the List: The highest review volume of any pizza spot in Barrie, with reviewers consistently praising the deep-fried pizza balls and fresh, high-quality toppings — though several reviews note a rigid no-substitution policy and slower service during busy periods.
Phone: (705) 728-7952
Address: 11 Victoria St, Barrie, ON L4N 6T3 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.2★ (3,355 reviews)
Paezano's Pizza & Marketplace
Family-owned pizzeria and gelato shop known for fresh, non-soggy wings.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise perfectly balanced toppings and a family-owned feel, with the gelato counter often mentioned as a bonus alongside the pizza.
Phone: (705) 722-1717
Address: 35 Cedar Pointe Dr, Barrie, ON L4N 5R7 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.6★ (814 reviews)
Sicilian Gourmet Pizza & Pasta
Italian-American pizza and pasta restaurant with a New York-style interior.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers praise the crispy-shelled panzerotti and hearty linguine jambalaya, though a couple of reviews describe inconsistent cheese portions and an off-tasting chicken dish on delivery orders — dine-in reviews skew notably more positive.
Phone: (705) 734-9999
Address: 225 Ferndale Dr S #4, Barrie, ON L4N 6B9 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.3★ (716 reviews)
Jimmy Chews [ Primo - Pizza ]
Neighbourhood pizzeria with in-house delivery drivers rather than third-party apps.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise the crust as a cut above typical chain pizza, with in-house delivery tracking and a standout Frezzo specialty pie mentioned repeatedly.
Phone: (705) 500-5224
Address: 55 Mulcaster St, Barrie, ON L4M 3M3 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.6★ (549 reviews)
City South Pizza
South-end pizzeria also serving spring rolls and momos alongside pizza.
Why It Made the List: Reviewers consistently praise generous topping portions and friendly counter service, with a large-pizza deal frequently called out as excellent value.
Phone: (705) 503-3221
Address: 477 Grove St E, Barrie, ON L4M 6M3 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.6★ (417 reviews)
Pizzaiolo
Modern, minimalist pizzeria known for creative specialty pies and a strong gluten-free crust.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers praise creative flavour combinations and an excellent gluten-free option, though a couple of reviews describe an inconsistent order or an unhelpful response when something went wrong — the food quality itself is consistently well-reviewed.
Phone: (705) 720-7373
Address: 409 Yonge St, Barrie, ON L4N 4E1 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.5★ (383 reviews)
Pizzeria Italia Restaurant
Family-owned Italian pizzeria open Thursday through Sunday.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers describe authentic, Italy-style thin crust pizza well above typical Barrie chains, though one detailed review describes a pre-made-tasting crust on one visit — the restaurant did offer a replacement when asked.
Phone: (705) 728-1421
Address: 18 Mulcaster St, Barrie, ON L4M 3M1 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.2★ (270 reviews)
PizzaCAPO
Late-night pizza and panzerotti shop open until 2am on weekends.
Why It Made the List: Most reviewers praise generously filled panzerotti and a chewy, well-topped crust, though one detailed review describes a pizza that arrived undercooked — worth specifying your preferred bake level if you're picky about crust doneness.
Phone: (705) 503-9990
Address: 4 Cedar Pointe Dr C, Barrie, ON L4N 1C2 (View on Map)
Rating: 4.5★ (206 reviews)
Are You a Local Business Owner?
Get featured on Momo Barrie Magazine and connect with thousands of local customers. It's affordable, effective, and supports our mission to help Barrie businesses thrive.
Get Featured for only $9.99/monthFrequently Asked Questions
Who are the top Pizza Restaurants in Barrie?
The businesses listed above are among Barrie's most established Pizza Restaurants providers, based on local presence and service reputation.
How do I choose the right Pizza Restaurants provider in Barrie?
Compare services offered, request quotes from a few providers, and check recent local reviews before deciding.
How often is this list updated?
MBM reviews this list periodically for accuracy. See the "Updated" date below.
Updated: September 2026
