Top 10 Italian Restaurants in Barrie
Il Buco Ristorante
An icon of Barrie's fine dining scene, Il Buco offers an intimate, upscale experience with authentic Italian cuisine in a historic building overlooking Kempenfelt Bay.
Looking for the best Italian Restaurants in Barrie? This list ranks 10 local Italian Restaurants businesses, selected for local presence, service quality, and relevance to Barrie-area customers.
How We Selected This List
MBM ranks Barrie businesses in this category by local presence, service breadth, and relevance to Barrie-area customers. Listings are reviewed periodically for accuracy — see the "Updated" date below.
Why It May Be Worth Considering: The top choice for special occasions and romantic dinners, known for its exceptional ambiance, service, and culinary excellence.
Website: ilbucoristorante.com
Phone: (705) 735-9595
Address: 31 Dunlop St E, Barrie, ON L4M 1A2 (View on Map)
La Cantina Ristorante
A beloved, family-owned establishment serving Barrie for decades. La Cantina is known for its warm atmosphere and generous portions of classic Italian-American fare.
Why It May Be Worth Considering: Perfect for family gatherings seeking comforting, time-tested dishes in a warm, welcoming setting.
Website: lacantinabarrie.ca
Phone: (705) 728-1111
Address: 149 Dunlop St E, Barrie, ON L4M 1B1 (View on Map)
Pizzeria Italia Restaurant
A Barrie institution since 1965, Pizzeria Italia is famous for its signature pizza and also serves a full menu of classic Italian fare in a bustling, family-friendly environment.
Why It May Be Worth Considering: A go-to spot for classic pizza and pasta night, with a long-standing reputation for consistent quality.
Website: pizzeriaitalia.ca
Phone: (705) 728-0000
Address: 110 Bradford St, Barrie, ON L4N 3B2 (View on Map)
Groovy Tuesday's Bistro
This cozy bistro features a seasonally inspired menu with a strong, modern Italian influence, focusing on fresh, locally sourced ingredients for an innovative dining experience.
Why It May Be Worth Considering: Ideal for foodies who appreciate creative, chef-driven dishes with a contemporary spin on Italian flavours.
Website: groovytuesdaysbistro.com
Phone: (705) 739-8822
Address: 87 Dunlop St E, Barrie, ON L4M 1A6 (View on Map)
Urban Dish
Urban Dish provides a stylish, contemporary dining experience with a global menu featuring standout Italian-inspired dishes. A popular spot for a chic night out.
Why It May Be Worth Considering: A great choice for a trendy dinner or date night, offering a polished atmosphere and creative cuisine.
Website: urbandish.ca
Phone: (705) 792-0909
Address: 371 Mapleview Dr W, Barrie, ON L4N 9B7 (View on Map)
Limoncello Bistro
A south-end hidden gem offering an authentic taste of Southern Italy. Limoncello uses fresh ingredients to create classic dishes in a bright, modern, and welcoming space.
Why It May Be Worth Considering: A fantastic, highly-rated choice for authentic Italian food in Barrie's south end.
Website: limoncellobistro.ca
Phone: (705) 728-8880
Address: 411 Huronia Rd, Unit 4, Barrie, ON L4N 9B3 (View on Map)
PIE Wood Fired Pizza Joint
Specializing in authentic Neapolitan-style pizza, PIE uses a traditional wood-fired oven for a perfect crust. The atmosphere is casual, modern, and energetic.
Why It May Be Worth Considering: The top destination for authentic, wood-fired Neapolitan pizza in a modern, fun setting.
Website: eatmypie.ca
Phone: (705) 725-9777
Address: 11 Victoria St, Barrie, ON L4N 0G2 (View on Map)
AvocoBar
AvocoBar combines healthy eating with Italian roots, specializing in fresh panini, salads, and pasta bowls in a fast-casual setting.
Why It May Be Worth Considering: An excellent option for a healthy, quick, and delicious Italian meal, especially for lunch.
Website: avocobar.com
Phone: (705) 252-3777
Address: 411 Bayfield St, Unit 4, Barrie, ON L4M 5A1 (View on Map)
Nino's Italian Restaurant
A classic, family-style restaurant in Barrie's north end offering a comforting menu of Italian favourites. Known for its friendly service and neighbourhood feel.
Why It May Be Worth Considering: A reliable and welcoming spot for a no-fuss Italian dinner in Barrie's north end.
Website: Verify directly with business
Phone: (705) 726-2346
Address: 341 Bayfield St, Barrie, ON L4M 3C2 (View on Map)
Paezano's Pizza
A local favourite for classic, stone-baked pizza and panzerotti. Paezano's is a casual, takeout-focused spot delivering consistent quality and flavour.
Why It May Be Worth Considering: A top contender for satisfying, old-school pizza or panzerotti, known for great quality and value.
Website: paezanospizza.ca
Phone: (705) 737-3333
Address: 20 Bell Farm Rd, Unit 12, Barrie, ON L4M 6E4 (View on Map)
Are You a Local Business Owner?
Get featured on Momo Barrie Magazine and connect with thousands of local customers looking for your services. It's affordable, effective, and supports our mission to help Barrie businesses thrive.
Get Featured for only $9.99/monthFrequently Asked Questions
Who are the top Italian Restaurants in Barrie?
The businesses listed above are among Barrie's most established Italian Restaurants providers, based on local presence and service reputation.
How do I choose the right Italian Restaurants provider in Barrie?
Compare services offered, request quotes from a few providers, and check recent local reviews before deciding.
How often is this list updated?
MBM reviews this list periodically for accuracy. See the "Updated" date below.
Updated: September 2026
